Paper Towns is a great read about two teenagers in high school and
the mystery of love and all that romance entails. The bigger picture
of the novel can be read as the problems with different social
circles that are involved in high school. Throughout the story, the
social hierarchy of high school is often referenced. The
stereotypical popular crowd and band geek crowd are present in the
book, as well as stereotypical characters from each of those crowds.
Margo is from the popular crowd and not even a quarter of the way
through the book do we see her demanding upon Quenten, an innocent
boy from the band geek crowd. While John Greene does a good job of
challenging the stereotype of the popular girl by having her hang out
with Quenten and talk about not wanting to be part of the popular
crowd, he still plays into the images people have of the
stereotypical high school students. A good theme to be taught out of
this book is the topic of agency. Many times throughout the book,
especially during the revenge-escapade, things happen to Quenten
without his control (Margo showing up in his bedroom). But not soon
after that, Quenten is called upon to make decisions of his own, like
participating in parts of the revenge and even picking a victim for
himself. Many high school students can relate to this theme-and this
book as a whole-because there is always someone from opposing crowds
that you just don't get along with-but that doesn't mean you seek
revenge on them...or do you?
This text depicts adolescence as reckless and careless. Although the
kids are in school and seem to already have a path for next year in
college, they do little to better themselves throughout the book in
the context of school. Not to mention the fact that they stayed out
till almost morning pulling pranks on other classmates. The chances
of students actually doing this in high school are pretty slim, one,
because most parents would notice their kid leaving in their car and,
two, because students are usually getting ready for the next day at
school instead of driving recklessly around the city. That being
said, this text brings up a good point about revenge and
responsibility for actions, and if some actions do indeed require
revenge. It would be a good topic to discuss with students and to
teach them the (actual) repercussions of actions.
I
think this text definitely appeals to adolescence because it's a fun
and interesting story to follow along with. Whether you belong to the
popular crowd or the nerdy crowd, I'm sure students can relate to the
story line in one way or another. In high school, the popular kids
really do think they can order their friends and the people lower
than them on the social tier around. It's a good read for kids who
can relate to Quenten because he has had his eye on Margo forever and
he finally got his chance to be friends with her and to hangout with
her-a feeling a lot of kids can probably relate to. The idea of
identity as it pertains to high school is a hard concept to get your
head around when you're in the moment: a lot of high schoolers just
don't know who they are. I think Paper
Towns is
a great story to read to realize that a
lot
of high schoolers feel like that; not everyone knows who they are
like you think they do. And along with identity comes the people who
you identify with: your friends. People make friends with others for
many different reasons, and sometimes the people you call your
friends may not be your friends at all. Betrayal, loss of trust, and
lying are what led Margo to tell her “friends” that her
relationship with them “lays with the fish.” Many, many, many
high school students can relate to the idea of loss of friendship as
well.
This text would probably receive a C from me. I love the idea of the
book and I loved reading it, but it didn't particularly stick out to
me. I think a lot less can be learned from this book than other
books, while a lot can still be gained from it.
No comments:
Post a Comment